Once again on the trade unions, the current moment and on the mistake of comrade Trotsky
a Theoretical disagreements.
P "Two tendencies" and Trotsky's faction G + My "vacillations" and
("substitution of the question")
my war
)
"Tsektran poison" ( + "Direction and tempo")
+ "Bureaucratic" approach in
Trotsky
7 "Not a word" vs * "fusion" "4 points"
+ economic approach
Ь Renunciation of the IX Congress of the RCP
Appointedness, yes or no?
Zinoviev's "duplicity" (Trotsky, 27).
t **One should not exaggerate.**
С **Every cloud has a silver lining.** "Themes" (not chapters) are as follows:
Our disagreements (a.)
Factionalism and Trotsky's factional enthusiasms (P + ?)
Renunciation of the IX Congress of the RCP (a)
Danger of exaggerating the divergence (e)
Every cloud has a silver lining (C)

1. Factional nature of Trotsky's speech
on December 25 =
= party danger**.
2. Split in Tsektran =
= political danger.
collective labor
2 tendencies. Factional attacks shaking up
Formal democracy vs Glavpolitput' "Zof"
* — v e rsu s— against.
** Points 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 9, 11, 12, 12 bis, 15 and 16 are crossed out
by V. I. Lenin.

3. Source
of this double danger:
Nov. 8th Plenum 3 and disruption of the commission.
4. Perhaps the depth and seriousness
of the disagreements justify this? The essence of the divergence, — theoretical analysis
of theses, etc.
5. Political
and (vs)
economic approach eclecticism.
6. School and (vs) "integral part of the
apparatus" eclecticism.
7. "Production democracy"?
8. "Soviet trade unionism"? "Defense
of material and spiritual interests"?
petitioners?
9. The party program and its fulfillment
or coarsening?
10. Shock work and equalitarianism?
11. "Fusion". Why keep silent about it?
"not a word from Zinoviev and Lenin"?
12. Four points in my speech on Dec. 30th, 4.
a) ordinary democratism
b) production propaganda
— vs democratic "atmosphere"
c) natural premiums
d) disciplinary courts.
13. "Renunciation" of the IX Congress of the RCP
Zinoviev's "duplicity".
Appointedness, yes or no?
14. Direction,
tempo, situation in Trotsky propagandistic and administrative approach
15. Should trade unions resolve conflicts?
Syndicalist infatuation.
+ 3 bis buffer?
+ 5 bis: Political
maneuvering and (vs) economic improvement
+ 12 bis. "Tsektran poison"
(Incident with Rudzutak's theses)
Zof and "scapegoats"

My
"platform":
16. Back from practical and business work to theses (to waste
time on politics)
approach and situation
17. One should not exaggerate divergences
(not "rejection")
18. "Every cloud has a silver lining"
Buffer and "dirty linen".
19. EE =
Factional speeches party danger.
Split in Tsektran political danger.
Theoretical inaccuracies and incorrect tendency
Back from business and practical work to "theses" and "principles"
4 "points"
Theoretical disagreements
1. Political and
("politics" and "economics" ("buffer" economic "school" and "apparatus")
point approach (or point of view)
of view)
2. Eclecticism or dialectics?
3. "Production
democracy".
Formal democratism vs Glavpolitput' (thesis 23)... Trotsky, 67, Bukharin
4. Soviet trade unionism or incorrect assessment of "tempo"
and situation
5. The party program and its simplification and worsening by Trotsky.
"Defense of material and spiritual interests" and "funeral
rites". Bukharin and Trotsky, p. 48.
Faction (founded by Trotsky on Dec. 25, 1920). For a short time.
(8 factional attacks).
"Two tendencies" because of the production role or because of
the approach to the masses?

Buffer group and buffer point of view (eclecticism and dialectics) *
One should not exaggerate disagreements (or divergences?)
*
From the word "Faction" to the word "dialectics" crossed out
by V. I. Lenin.
"rejection", Trotsky, 34 disrupt the discussion
Trotsky, 65

[ Every cloud has a silver lining, 'j + "buffer group"
\ ("dirty linen
? kitchen
Of the Business
1 Central Committee"?)
J Yard?
How Lenin mistakenly seized upon the "Tsektran lightning rod" and how Trotsky
exposed me * "Tsektran poison" (and incident with Zof)
"Fusion" and why it's better to keep silent about it because
(1) idly without facts
\2) no need to scare pointlessly **
}
Trotsky, 31
Dektran...
"Let's assume that a mistake"
Trotsky, 24
Trotsky, 32 not as litigating parties, but as participants
in common work
Propagandist and administrator's approach
[propagandist and "economic manager"] administrative "school"
["agitator" in Trotsky p. 28] "propagandist" and administrator (Trotsky,
p. 27)
Direction (thesis 28) and tempo (thesis 39)
and "situation" (thesis 28 i. {.)
a 6. Equalitarianism and shock work
Conflicts will be resolved by trade unions (thesis 33)?
Example of infatuation, exaggeration.
Bureaucratic point of view in Trotsky г /з and V» i
\correct the top/
Appointedness, yes or no? Trotsky, 25 "Scapegoats". Trotsky, 25
"special question", according to Trotsky, 22 "Duplicity"
of Zinoviev (Trotsky, 27)
(Trotsky, 67)
(cf *** thesis 24:
on what compulsion should rely)
*
Paragraph crossed out by V. I. Lenin.
** Paragraph crossed out by V. I. Lenin.
*** — confer — compare.

OUTLINES OF THE PLAN FOR SECTIONS
"POLITICS AND ECONOMICS. DIALECTICS AND ECLECTICISM"
AND "DIALECTICS AND ECLECTICISM. "SCHOOL" AND "APPARATUS""
1) eclecticism of the buffer
2) dialectics and eclecticism
3) school and apparatus
(on one and on the other side)
4) and as an apparatus, they = school

500 x 5 = 7 500 x 5 = 37 500
37.5 vs 6000 thousand
1% 5
5) Bukharin Jan. 3rd in Piter
6) Trotsky's shaking up
"a spirit of hostility develops" administrator vs propagandist (Trotsky, 27)
7) state — compulsion
party — exclusion trade unions — school.
1) Wide discussion
Who wanted it?
2) "Fusion"
dispute about it?
Who started it?
"staccato": 2 "sides", and not 2 2 2 ? for what?
when? to whom? in connection with what?
Formal and dialectical logic
a) comprehensively
b) in development
c) human practice y compris*
E = d) "no abstract truth". "Truth is always concrete".
from the glass to trade unions: school and apparatus...
in general? Yes!
In the era of the dictatorship of the proletariat — "first steps from capitalism to communism" (program of the RCP)
apparatus = when they merge (neither trade unions nor state)
* — including.

now, however, school and as communist training = school
and as apparatus = school of the apparatus, school =
= "school of administrative-technical management of production"
not on one side a school, on the other — an apparatus, but on
both and on all sides a **school**.
Even more concretely.
Apparatus? Yes. 1500 x 5 = 7.5; 7.5 X 5 = 37.5 vs