Trotsky:
Trotsky 's 'The Role and Tasks of the Trade Unions'
1) product of collective
Preface — faction :
work (Cf. thesis
2) 'a whole series'

f.*)
3) pamphlet-platform.
thesis 1. a limine ** incorrect. 'Backward' not those (but Trotsky), not there
and to the theses from practice to bureaucratism from democracy
thesis 4 (i. f.) 'choose between 2 ten dencies (Faction!)... in the area
of the trade union movement' thesis 5. 'The greatest contradiction
within the workers' state'
Incorrect!!!
thesis 6. Program: 'to come to the actual aa thesis 6:
concentration of all administration program of the entire national economy
as a single economic whole' (consequently, including agriculture!!)
'In practice... we... moved away'??? Incorrect .
* — in fine — at the end.
** — from the threshold; in principle.
*** — fundamentally incorrect!
The entire
Section I grundfalsch !!!

thesis 7 thesis 7 (i. f. p. 8): 'eliminated' 'class economic
struggle.' Incorrect !
thesis 8, thesis 8 (i. f. p. 9): 'all^> truncated, unsystematic'??? Incorrect .
. 'professional conservatism in the leading stratum'
???Frac- 'in the personnel of the leading tional bodies'
attacks thesis 8 a leap
N. B.:
+ bureaucratic
tendency to direct attention to the 'tops'
i. f. task:
'organize production' (italics) = program
I
Theoreti - \ Incorrect. Unequal.
callyincorrect \ ( 'To come' to the actual
) concentration)...
No.
thesis 9. (p. 10): ... 'directly' (nonsense!)
thesis 9 (i. f.) 'there cannot be' specialists in organizing production and
in the trade union movement (nonsense! There can!!).
thesis 10. 'concentration in the hands of the unions of all management of production'
( = program). No.
Incorrect.
thesis 11. (program = 'to come to the actual concentration and
not of production) ... (each branch of industry)' the sis 10 i. f.)
(77)
. 'This point of view is formally,
i. e. inwords acknowledged
by the majority of professionals. So, Comrade Tomsky'...'
Quote from Lozovsky...
N. 13
(not this one)
1 0 0 times smarter bb factional | attack 'in words' |
!

thesis 12.
'As a result of the process... to
/n.b.)
the extent of progress (bis) create jointly'...' thesis 12 (both amalgamation and merging
according to Lozovsky is correct)
'All the sharper against amalgamation'
Tomsky and Lozovsky thesis 14. i. f. 'develop the spirit of corporate
seclusion' thesis 15. 'antipathy to new workers' thesis 15 ...'support remnants of guild spirit'...'
thesis 16. Ryazanov retains for the unions 'the protection or defense of their material
and spiritual interests' 'Soviet trade-unionism'.
Nonsense. Ryazanov is right here.
(...'rejects... leaders '...')
55 factional attack 'rejects' her fractional attack (i. f.) Tomsky gets confused
with Ryazanov nonsense!
Bureaucratic point of view: lead ers of the All-Russian Central Council of Trade Unions are to blame
i. f. 'main task: regrouping,
reorganization, re-education of the unions' (in accordance with the tasks of organizing
production)
((NB re-education of the unions or re-education of 6 1/2 million
people? NB))
bureaucratism:
re-make the tops!

thesis thesis thesis thesis thesis thesis
17. 'not an advocate, but an organizer'
(nonsense! // both, and that)
'the trade union increases its (labor) mechanization' ((syndicalist
enthusiasm)
(cf. Shlyapnikov)
| contra 18
(from the resolution of the Central Committee
7. XII.01 *)
19. 'production re-education... primarily for professional
workers... refreshed... Leaders'...' bureaucratic point of view
refresh the tops
20. Production
propaganda ('an integral part (?) of production education (?)'...'
'... must constitute the most important content of the life
and work of the trade unions'
20 i. f. the working 'mass' must 'get to know' the economic manager and 'renew, strengthen
trust in him'.
__
Iv.v. * the subject is not right. He
I must win her over, not she him
Incorrect!
Not 'the most important', but one of the important ones
21. The striving of 'some professionals'
to present 'the current ideological struggle' (?)
as a struggle between appointments and democracy 'is fundamentally false'.
| And the incorrect application of appointments?|
'Appointments' = inevitable addition to 'production impotence'?
22. Workers' democracy only
as production democracy.
('Substitution')
I of the question? J nonsense!
forgotten and the level of culture and 1,000 other other things
* — vice versa — on the contrary.

thesis 23. 'A striking example of formally democratic' — Glavpolit-
G 'substitution' )
path
\ of the question?/ 'some professionals'— 'condemn' ...
(for what?? ameasure, not 'principle'...)
thesis 24. compulsion must be 'based' o n ...
all and broad work of involvement '' organization raising the general
cultural level...
that's the essence!
Measure!
Appropriate approach!
( be based!
< but you did not
I base yourself thesis 24. 'The conservative wing of the professional
organization'
...'Tomsky'?
Ch Ch
)
factional I
I attack I thesis 25. 'To work in a military fashion' means
'also by means of persuasion' thesis 26. The struggle against bureaucratism...
above all 'an integral part' of the work of trade unions? (Blurted out!).
Not so much the accumulation of control bodies, but rectification.
(Very good! For Rabkrin!)
Excellent!
And the measure ?
And the approach?
thesis 28. The objection that there is no need to force,
Ha-ha!! Here is force, that one must take into account the level, 'misses the mark'.
The tempocanbedifferent (Trotsky's entire mistake is a mistake of tempo:
NB
he rushed!)

thesis 28 i. f. 'One must observe the direction not to take
steps backward, when the situation decisively demands steps
forward'.
The crux!
What kind of 'situation'?
Conflict of Tsektran with the waterworkers ?
EE * =
NB
= Compromising the correct course with extremes and violating the tempo!
thesis 29 i. f. 'Opposes the new production course... the conservative part of the professional
bureaucracy' ftO factional attack thesis 'Masses'!! 'Tangible
29: for the masses economic successes'...'
Trotsky
/ ha-ha!!
for economic cf. concluding successes, ] speech (of Trotsky
Lenin for politics
VI. Practical Conclusions thesis 30. ...'A number of organizational-G Ha-ha!