Dear friends,

I have read Rosa’s new book *Die Akkumulation des Kapitals*. She has made a frightful mess of it! Distorted Marx. I am very glad that Pannekoek, Eckstein and O. Bauer have unanimously condemned her and said against her what I in 1899 said against the Narodniks. I am going to write about Rosa in *Prosveshcheniye* for No. 4, 1913.

Koba has managed to write a long (for three issues of *Prosveshcheniye*) article on the national question. Good! We must fight for the truth against the separatists and opportunists from the Bund and from among the liquidators.

There is some movement of the waters towards Russia: more are going home from abroad to work than before.

Trotsky, they say, is sulking against *Luch*.

Well, must finish all the same. Big greetings from Malinovsky and from everyone. I firmly shake your hand.

Yours, Lenin