**2. CHARACTERIZATION OF DELEGATES ACCORDING TO PROTOCOLS{173}**

Egorov: I) Incident with the CC 1) requests a break: 36; 2) requests a final word: 40; 3) accuses Pavlovich: 42–43. – II) Speech against the Bund: 93. – III) Significance of recognizing the organ of *Iskra*: 138, 140. – IV) For one center, for a popular organ, for defining the boundaries of the Central Committee's competence: 155. – V) Closing the list of speakers is a formal violation: 159 (for the Bund){174}. – VI) Hisses at Plekhanov: 169–170. – VII) For equality of languages: 172, 174, 181 ("to bring the congress to its senses"){175}. – VIII) The agrarian program is unclear: 192 (theoretically convinced: 197). "Far from being carried away by the editorial board's enthusiasm for the peasant movement": 205. – IX) Unclear in § 1: 238 (the only speech on § 1). – X) The Party Council is unclear: 267 and 269 (moderate){176}. – XI) Limitation of the Central Committee's power: 272, 273. – XII) "Killing" *Rabocheye Delo* and leaving the hall{177}, 283–284. – XIII) Demand for a vote on *Yuzhny Rabochiy*: 312, 313, 314 ("a lie" that *Yuzhny Rabochiy* = *Rabochaya Mysl*, cf. 356 (against Bonch)). – XIV) Principles are lost (around personalities): 337. – XV) Support for the opposition. Unclear, 359.{178}

Popov: I) Incident with the CC: 41, 43, 45, 55 (offended NB). – II) For *Iskra* (Central Organ) – 140, 145. – III) For one center: 154 (a secondary question, whether 3 or 2 from the editorial board in the Council). Completely unimportant (NB), whether the Central Organ or the Central Committee (NB) 158.{179} – IV) For equality of languages ter[193]: 174. ("Such an atmosphere." 182). – V) § 1 – for Martov: 241 ("a great difference in understanding membership in the organization." NB). – VI) For limiting the power of the Central Committee. 272. – VII) For *Yuzhny Rabochiy* – 312, 314, 316 ("now everything is clear"{180}). – VIII) For the six: "delicate assignments"{181}: 322. – IX) Refusal to elect to the Central Committee: 338.

Makhov: I) Against placing the Bund question first: 32–33 ("a sore point": democracy or centralization NB). – II) For the CC in the incident: 46. – III) For equality of languages ter: 172–173. – IV) The agrarian program is "not social-democratic": 201, demagogy, 202; the peasantry into classes – 202, id.[194] 216. Against the entire agrarian program: 211. + Liberal. 212 (NB 211 and others: a great muddler{182}). – V) Revolution like a riot, 206 (laughter). – VI) Against supporting the revolutionary movement (laughter) – 226. Contra[195]: 229 (and the bourgeoisie is revolutionary)!! – VII) § 1 bis[196] with Martov. – VIII) Abstains from voting on the Bund. Would have voted for § 2: p. 289–290 (Muddler!!){183}. – IX) For *Svoboda*{184}: 307. – X) "improper" – for the editorial board: 323, id. 328,{185}

Lvov: I) Against the Bund: 33, 78, and 89 (good speeches). – II) For equality of languages ter. 172. – III) On § 1 bis for Martov – 254. – IV) For *Svoboda* – 307 and 319.

Tsarev: I) For one center: 263. – II) For equality of languages (2 abstentions and 1 vote for Martynov) – 172. – III) On § 1 bis for me. – IV) For the editorial board: 324 (vulgarity NB). – V) Election of one editor: 335.{186}

Belov: I) Equality of languages (1 vote for and 2 against us). – II) § 1 bis for Martov. – III) For *Yuzhny Rabochiy*: 308. – IV) For the six: 335.

Pavlovich:

1) Against *Borba*. 39
2) Incident with the CC. 41, 43, 45
3) Equality of languages – for us
4) § 1 – 247 – for me (good speech 247)
cf. 255 – irony
5) For the Central Organ's dominance over the Central Committee – 264
6) For the trio – 328.

Sorokin:

1) Against *Borba* – 39
2) Equality of languages for us (ter)
3) § 1 for me (bis)
4) Against the six – NB – 328
5) idem "on Lenin's malicious intent"{187} – 339
C) – on Deutsch's words p. 351.

Lyadov:

1) Against the Bund (briefly) – 70, 120
2) For *Iskra* – 140
3) Equality of languages + + +
4) To throw out "poor children"{188} – 180
5) Businesslike amendments to the agrarian program – 188
(a passim[197])
6) § 1+ +
7) Against *Yuzhny Rabochiy* (well) – 316
8) » 6-ki – 326.

Gorin:

1) Response to Martynov – 119 (cf. 121 and 166){189}
2) For *Iskra* – 137 and 141
3) Agrarian program, amendments – 191, 196, 212
4) Equality of languages + + +
5) § 1 + +
6) Against *Yuzhny Rabochiy* – 317
7) » 6-ki —325.

Glebov:

1) Influence of the Central Committee from activity…{190} 158
2) For dissolving *Yuzhny Rabochiy* – 316
3) Against the six – 328.

Lensky:

1) Against the Voronezh Committee: 50
2) Equality of languages against us: 172, 173
(2 out of 3)
3) § 1 – against me bis.

Stepanov:

1) 77 – Against the Bund – 77
2) Equality of languages: abstained + bis for us
3) § 1 —for me bis.

Gorsky:

1) Equality of languages – , 0, + (+ for us)
2) § 1 + and + bis (for me).

Karsky:

1) Remark (minor) against the CC – 55
2) Against the Bund: 65, 81, 89
NB
3) Response to Martynov and on the party – 126{191}
4) Equality of languages – – —
5) For the agrarian program: 207, 213, 222
6) § 1 speech: 239 (—). – —

Rusoe:

1) Against Bundism: 65 and 71, 104
2) Equality of languages – – —
3) Agrarian program businesslike amendment – 225
4) § 1 – speech: 247
5) Council. For me – 265
6) On new Bundism: 296, 302{192}
7) Against *Yuzhny Rabochiy*: 314
8) Against the six: 325.

Bekov:

1) Against the Bund – 81
2) Equality of languages – – —
3) § 1 + +

Lange:

1) Against *Borba*: 38
2) » Bund: 69
3) Agrarian [program]. Unclear sections. Why not expropriate all the land? || NB
Not charmed by the agrarian program – 205.
Proposes changes in editing: 225
4) Equality of languages ter for us
5) § 1 bis for me
6) On the Council against me (265) – || NB
7) Against *Yuzhny Rabochiy* – 315 —
good – NB
8) » 6-ki – 327. – NB.

Gusev:

1) Equality of languages ter for us
2) Speech on the agrarian program very practical – 203
3) § 1 for me
4) Cannot shield the Central Committee from the influence of the Central Organ – 265
5) Against *Yuzhny Rabochiy* – 312 and 314 (NB)
6) Speech against the six – 326.

Muravyev:

1) Against the Bund – p. 76
2) For *Iskra* – 139 and 141
3) Equality of languages – ter for us
4) For the agrarian program (trifles) – 216 and 217
5) For § 1 (248) and bis
6) Against *Yuzhny Rabochiy* – 313 and 315
7) » 6-ki – 321 (meaning: 353 NB).